Which burt's bees lip shimmer should i get? ?

i just finished a nutmeg burt's bees lip shimmer and i want another one, but i'm not sure i want the same color. i have dark tan skin and dark lips, too. the nutmeg was alright, but sometimes it looked a little too bright and red, especially if i put more than one coat. i do like the sparkliness, though, which i don't see in like rhubarb and merlot. i'm thinking about coffee, fig, or papaya...what should i get?